Rohinton Mistry’s A Fine Balance (1995) is a monumental work of literature that captures the intricacies of human resilience amidst political and social turmoil in India. Set during the Emergency imposed by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi (1975–1977), the novel deftly explores the intersection of personal morality and systemic oppression, providing an expansive and harrowing portrait of Indian society.
The narrative centres on four characters brought together by circumstances beyond their control: Dina Dalal, a resolute widow determined to retain her independence; Maneck Kohlah, a young student displaced from his idyllic hill station home; and Ishvar and Omprakash Darji, two tailors who flee their village to escape caste-based violence. The quartet’s lives converge in a cramped apartment in an unnamed coastal city, a microcosm of India’s fractured social fabric. The novel unfolds as these characters grapple with their individual and collective struggles, navigating the complexities of trust, friendship, and survival.
Expanding the Scope of Indian Fiction
Mistry’s narrative transcends the Parsi community—a focal point in his earlier works—to encompass a broader spectrum of Indian society. The characters, drawn from different castes, classes, and religious backgrounds, reflect the diverse realities of India during a time of upheaval. Dina’s battle against societal and familial expectations, Ishvar and Om’s harrowing journey through caste violence, and Maneck’s disillusionment with urban life create a mosaic of experiences symbolic of the nation’s struggles. By weaving their lives together, Mistry highlights how individuals, separated by identity and history, are bound by shared vulnerabilities and resilience.
The novel’s spatial dynamics significantly shape its narrative. The unnamed city serves as both a backdrop and an active participant, embodying the stark power imbalances of Indian society. The characters’ movements through its streets, markets, and slums reveal a landscape fraught with tension, where the threat of violence and exploitation looms large. The juxtaposition of private and public spaces underscores the precariousness of their existence, with the apartment becoming both a refuge and a site of conflict.
The Vulnerability of the Body
A recurring theme in A Fine Balance is the vulnerability of the human body, which becomes a site of discrimination, violence, and control. Ishvar and Om, marked by their caste and occupation, endure dehumanising treatment, culminating in forced sterilisation that leaves them physically and emotionally scarred. Dina’s aversion to physical intimacy, rooted in past trauma, underscores how societal norms and personal experiences shape bodily autonomy. Mistry’s exploration of the body extends beyond individual suffering to reflect broader societal ills, exposing the intersections of power, privilege, and prejudice.
Narrative Style and Literary Influences
Mistry’s narrative style is a masterful blend of realism, symbolism, satire, and allegory. While the novel’s vivid depictions of daily life draw comparisons to the compassionate realism of Charles Dickens, its structural ambition and social critique evoke the works of Russian literary giants such as Dostoevsky and Tolstoy. Critics have also noted Mistry’s intertextual allusions to Indian authors like R. K. Narayan and Mulk Raj Anand and European influences like W. B. Yeats. This intertextuality enriches the narrative, situating it within a global literary tradition while remaining distinctly rooted in the Indian context.
The novel’s hybridity—blending realism with modernist elements and fabulist allegory—challenges simplistic categorisations. In his analysis of Mistry’s work, Peter Morey highlights how A Fine Balance transcends the confines of realism, offering a layered and multifaceted narrative. The use of the carnivalesque, for instance, subverts hierarchical structures, allowing moments of humour and absurdity to coexist with tragedy. This interplay of tones creates a rich tapestry that mirrors the complexities of life under an oppressive regime.
Ethical Quandaries and Human Resilience
At its core, A Fine Balance grapples with profound ethical questions about morality, justice, and the human condition. The Emergency’s suspension of civil liberties and imposition of draconian policies serve as a backdrop for the characters’ dilemmas. Dina’s struggle to maintain her independence in the face of societal and familial pressures, Maneck’s growing disenchantment with a nation in turmoil, and Ishvar and Om’s fight for dignity against caste-based violence underscore the moral complexities of survival.
Despite its often bleak portrayal of human suffering, the novel offers glimpses of hope through the characters’ capacity for love, compassion, and humour. The evolving relationships among Dina, Maneck, Ishvar, and Om reflect the resilience of the human spirit, even in the face of relentless adversity. Their shared camaraderie and mutual support counter the pervasive despair, illustrating the potential for solidarity and connection in the darkest times.
Critiques and Counterarguments
While A Fine Balance has been widely acclaimed, it is not without its critics. Some have argued that the novel’s portrayal of female characters lacks agency, with women often confined to traditional roles. However, Dina Dalal stands out as a dynamic and believable character who defies these stereotypes, asserting her independence and navigating her challenges with courage.
Though many criticise its voluminous nature, I will defend it tooth and nail. Rohinton Mistry’s A Fine Balance stretches over 620 pages, offering a profound and immersive experience for readers of contemporary fiction. Its exploration of themes such as history, the past, and their enduring influence on human lives raises pertinent questions about resilience, morality, and societal structures. While its length and density may initially seem daunting to some readers, the novel’s compelling narrative and richly drawn characters make it a rewarding journey for those willing to engage with its complexities. A Fine Balance may require patience for contemporary audiences accustomed to fast-paced fiction. Still, its vivid portrayal of life during India’s Emergency period provides an invaluable lens through which to understand the human condition under duress.
However, I agree with Critics as they have pointed out its unrelentingly bleak portrayal of human suffering, which some feel verges on the melodramatic. The overwhelming emphasis on tragedy risks overshadowing the moments of hope and resilience that punctuate the story. Additionally, certain female characters, with the notable exception of Dina Dalal, have been critiqued for lacking agency and depth, perpetuating traditional gender roles. This perceived imbalance may alienate readers seeking more progressive representations of women.
Another contentious issue is Mistry’s depiction of the Emergency era, which, while vivid and detailed, has been accused of being overly one-sided. The novel’s focus on the brutality and exploitation of the period leaves little room for narratives of resistance or survival, which could have provided a more nuanced perspective. Despite these critiques, Mistry’s intricate storytelling and ability to interweave personal and political narratives ensure that A Fine Balance contributes significantly to contemporary literature, inviting readers to reflect deeply on the intersections of history, identity, and humanity.
Legacy and Significance
A Fine Balance is a significant contribution to postcolonial literature. It captures the nuances of Indian society during one of its most turbulent periods. Its exploration of ethical dilemmas, the vulnerabilities of the body, and the complexities of human relationships resonate with universal themes, making it a work of enduring relevance. Mistry’s ability to depict the intersection of personal and political realities with compassion and insight underscores his mastery as a storyteller.
The novel’s enduring power lies in its ability to provoke reflection and empathy. By illuminating the lives of ordinary individuals caught in extraordinary circumstances, Mistry invites readers to confront uncomfortable truths about inequality, injustice, and the resilience of the human spirit. A Fine Balance is not merely a tale of suffering; it is a testament to humanity’s enduring strength in the face of overwhelming odds.
Conclusion:
A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry Book Review
-
Thoughtful Critic Rating
Summary
A Fine Balance… well, the novel might be ‘such a long journey’ for many readers who seldom take a sharp interest in knowing how history impacts our lives. Best suited for literary discourses and English literature classes, the novel may well be settled back in time comfortably. It has some intricate writing and sophisticated prose to offer, no doubt. Can you endure over 600 pages? Go ahead!
